2021 2(41)1

Methodology for Evaluating of Threats Influence on the Energy Security Level

Sukhodolia О.,  
Doctor of Science in Public Administration, Professor
National Institute for Strategic Studies, Kyiv,

Riabtsev G.,
Doctor of Science in Public Administration, Professor
National Institute for Strategic Studies, Kyiv,
National University of Kyiv-Mohyla Academy,

Kharazishvili Yu.
Doctor of Economic Sciences
National Institute for Strategic Studies, Kyiv,
Institute of Industrial Economics of the National Academy of Sciences of Ukraine, Kyiv

Citation Format
Sukhodolia, О. M., Riabtsev, G. L., Kharazishvili, Yu. M. (2021). Methodology for Evaluating of Threats Influence on the Energy Security Level. Visnyk ekonomichnoi nauky Ukrainy, 2 (41), рр. 3-16. DOI: https://doi.org/10.37405/1729-7206.2021.2(41).3-16


When an energy transition takes place, geopolitical confrontation over energy resources and technological leadership intensifies, models of energy market are changed, energy carriers are used as a weapon to achieve political goals in “hybrid” wars, the need increases to ensure the ability of authorities to neutralize threats to energy  security or reduce the negative consequences of their impact.
To solve this problem, methodology for evaluating of threats influence on the energy security level was developed. The methodology based on a systems approach. Threat evaluation consists of three stages – identification, analysis and, in fact, evaluation. Threat identification consists of its detection, registration and description. The used formula is: the “factor of influence” due to the presence of “vulnerability” can lead to “negative consequences”. The analysis consists of establishing the vulnerability of the object, as well as possible consequences of the threat impact, taking into account actions of authorities, aimed at its neutralization. Threat evaluation consists of establishing the total risk for each identified threat by combining corresponding probabilities and cumulative negative consequences, which are due to the vulnerability of the object.
The developed methodology was used to evaluate the Ukraine energy security threats as of 1 September 2021. It was found that the weightiest of them are: degradation of energy systems and networks, lack of professionalism in the policy-making, government interference in the energy markets functioning (as internal threats); cyberattacks, washing out of professional personnel, military actions (as external threats).
A systematic assessment of energy security threats will allow the authorities to better understand the phenomena, trends and factors that may complicate or make it impossible the implementation of Ukraine’s national interests in the energy sector.

systems approach, energy security, threat, risk, identification, evaluation.


  1. Bobrov, Ye. (2013). Enerhetychna bezpeka derzhavy [Energy security of the state]. Kyiv, University of Economics and Law «KROK». 308 р. [in Ukrainian].
  2. Shevtsov, A. I. (Ed). (2002). Enerhetychna bezpeka Ukrainy: stratehiia ta mekhanizmy zabezpechennia [Energy security of Ukraine: strategy and support mechanisms]. Dnipropetrovsk, Porohy [in Ukrainian].
  3. Stohnii, B. S., Kyrylenko, O. V., Denysiuk, S. P. (2006). Enerhetychna bezpeka Ukrainy: Svitovi ta natsionalni vyklyky [Energy security of Ukraine: World and national challenges]. Kyiv, Ukrainian encyclopedic knowledge. 408 р. [in Ukrainian].
  4. Prokip, A. V. (2011). Harantuvannia enerhetychnoi bezpeky: mynule, sohodennia, maibutnie [Guaranteeing energy security: past, present, future]. Lviv, ZUKC. 154 р. [in Ukrainian].
  5. Azzuni, A., Breyer, C. (2018). Definitions and dimensions of energy security: a literature review. WIREs Energy Environ. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1002/wene.268.
  6. Cherp, A., Jewell, J. (2014).The concept of energy security. Beyond the four As. Energy Policy, Vol. 75 (c), рр. 415-421. DOI: http://doi.org/10.1016/j.enpol.2014.09.005.
  7. Sovacool, B., Brown, M. (2010). Competing Dimensions of Energy Security: An International Perspective. Annual Review of Environment and Resources, No. 35:1, рр. 77–108. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1146/annurev-environ-042509-143035.
  8. The IEA Model of Short-term Energy Security (MOSES). (2011). Working paper. OECD/IEA.
  9. Winzer, C. (2012). Conceptualizing energy security. Energy Policy, Vol. 46 (C), рр. 36–48. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.enpol.2012.02.067.
  10. Sukhodolia, O. M. (2019). Problemy vyzna chennia sfery rehuliuvannia enerhetychnoi bezpeky [Problems of determining the sphere of energy security regulation]. Stratehichni priorytety – Strategic priorities, 1, рр. 5-17 [in Ukrainian].
  11. Sukhodolia, O. M. (2019). Cystemnyi pidkhid v otsiniuvanni stanu ta tsilepokladanni u sferi enerhetychnoi bezpeky [System approach in assessing the state and goal setting in the field of energy security]. Stratehichna panorama – Strategic panorama, 1-2, рр. 58-72 [in Ukrainian].
  12. Sukhodolia, O. M. (Ed). (2020).Enerhetychna bezpeka Ukrainy: metodolohiia systemnoho analizu ta stratehichnoho planuvannia [Energy security of Ukraine: methodology of system analysis and strategic planning]. Kyiv, NISS. 178 р. [in Ukrainian].
  13. Sukhodolia, O. M., Kharazishvili, Yu. M., Bobro, D. H. (2020). Metodolohichni zasady identyfikatsii ta stratehuvannia rivnia enerhetychnoi bezpeky Ukrainy [Methodological principles of identification and stra tegizing the level of energy security of Ukraine]. Ekonomika Ukrainy – Economy of Ukraine, 6 (703), рр. 20-42. DOI: https://doi.org/10.15407/economyukr.2020.06.020 [in Ukrainian].
  14. Kharazishvili, Yu. M. (2019). Systemna bezpeka staloho rozvytku: instrumentarii otsinky, rezervy ta stratehichni stsenarii realizatsii [System security of sustainable development: assessment tools, reserves and strategic implementation scenarios]. Kyiv, ІІЕ of NAS of Ukraine. 304 р. [in Ukrainian].
  15. Kharazishvili, Yu., Kwilinski, A., Sukhodolia, O. et. al. (2021). The Systemic Approach for Estimating and Strategizing Energy Security: The Case of Ukraine. Energies, Vol. 14, 2126. DOI: https://doi.org/10.3390/en14082126.
  16. Pro natsionalnu bezpeku : Zakon Ukrainy vid 21.06.2018 r. № 2469-VIII [On national security: Law of Ukraine of June 21, 2018 № 2469-VIII]. Retrieved from https://zakon.rada.gov.ua/laws/show/2469-19 [in Ukrainian].
  17. ISO 31000. Risk management. Retrieved from https://www.iso.org/iso-31000-risk-management.html.
  18. Risk assessment methodologies for critical infrastructure protection. Part II: A new approach. Retrieved from http://publications.jrc.ec.europa.eu/repository/bitstream/JRC96623/lbna27332enn.pdf.
  19. Gig, J. Van. (1981). Prikladnaya obshchaya teoriya sistem [Applied General Systems Theory]. In 2 vol. Moscow, Mir. Vol. 2. 730 p. [in Russian].
  20. Pro skhvalennia Stratehii enerhetychnoi bezpeky: rozporiadzhennia Kabinetu Ministriv Ukrainy vid 04 ser. 2021 r. № 907-r [On approval of the Energy Security Strategy: order of the Cabinet of Ministers of Ukraine dated 04 Aug. 2021 № 907-r]. Retrieved from https://www.kmu.gov.ua/npas/pro-shvalennya-strategiyi-energetichn-a907r [in Ukrainian].
  21. Sukhodolia, O. M., Kharazishvili, Yu. M., Bobro, D. H., Riabtsev, H. L., Zavhorodnia, S. P. (2021). Vyznachennia rivnia enerhetychnoi bezpeky Ukrainy [Determining the level of energy security of Ukraine]. Kyiv, NISS. 71 р. [in Ukrainian].
  22. Kharazishvili, Yu. M., Liubich, O. O. (2006). Systemne modeliuvannia sotsialno-ekonomichnoho rozvytku [System modeling of social and economic development]. Bankivska sprava – Banking, 3, рр. 46-65 [in Ukrainian].
  23. Liashenko, V. I., Kharazishvili, Yu. M. (2016). Stratehichni stsenarii strukturnoho rozvytku promyslovykh rehioniv Ukrainy [Strategic scenarios of structural development of industrial regions of Ukraine]. Visnyk ekonomichnoi nauky Ukrainy, 2, рр. 113-126 [in Ukrainian].
  24. Amosha, O. I., Kharazishvili, Yu. M., Liashenko, V. I. et al. (2018). Modernizatsiia ekonomiky promys lovykh rehioniv Ukrainy v umovakh detsentralizatsii upravlinnia [Modernization of the economy of industrial regions of Ukraine in terms of decentralization of management]. Kyiv, ІІЕ of NAS of Ukraine. 300 р. [in Ukrainian].
  25. Kharazishvili, Yu. M., Liashenko, V. I. (2019). Stratehichni stsenarii staloho rozvytku ta instytutsiini umovy dosiahnennia [Strategic scenarios of sustainable development and institutional conditions of achievement]. Ekonomichnyi visnyk Donbasu – Economic Herald of the Donbas, 3(57), рр. 282-302. DOI: https://doi.org/10.12958/1817-3772-2019-3(57)-282-302 [in Ukrainian].
  26. Kharazishvili, Yu. M. (2017). Svitlo ta tin ekonomiky Ukrainy: rezervy zrostannia ta modernizatsii [Light and shadow of Ukraine’s economy: reserves of growth and modernization]. Ekonomika Ukrainy Economy of Ukraine, 4(665), рр. 22-45 [in Ukrainian].
  27. Kharazishvili, Yu. M. (2021). Svidotstvo pro reiestratsiiu avtorskoho prava № 105927 Ukraina na tvir. Naukovyi tvir «Metod kovznoi matrytsi dlia vyznachennia dynamichnykh vahovykh koefitsiientiv» [Certificate of copyright registration № 105927 Ukraine for the work. Scientific work “Sliding matrix method for determining dynamic weights”]. Register 07/02/2021 [in Ukrainian].
  28. Kharazishvili, Yu. M. (2021). Svidotstvo pro reiestratsiiu avtorskoho prava № 109405 Ukraina na tvir. Naukovyi tvir «Stokhastychnyi metod vyznachennia hranychnykh znachen indykatoriv bezpeky» [Certificate of copyright registration № 109405 Ukraine for the work. Scientific work “Stochastic method for determining the limit values of safety indicators”]. Register 11/12/2021 [in Ukrainian].

Full Text (.pdf)